Talk:Covert Operations (Long War) - Revision history

Riw: /* EXALT Forces here? */

2021-11-13T11:55:14Z

EXALT Forces here?

← Older revision		Revision as of 11:55, 13 November 2021
Line 2:		Line 2:
	DjinnFor, first of all, great job adding all these details. Though the tables in EXALT Forces are basically a duplicate of what is already in EXALT Missions article. It is not a good practice to have the same tables in two places. Consider removing them from here, as this article is meant to cover mainly the strategic aspect of EXALT. The details about EXALT forces belong more to EXALT Missions article. [[User:Riw\|Riw]] ([[User talk:Riw\|talk]]) 22:03, 12 November 2021 (CET)		DjinnFor, first of all, great job adding all these details. Though the tables in EXALT Forces are basically a duplicate of what is already in EXALT Missions article. It is not a good practice to have the same tables in two places. Consider removing them from here, as this article is meant to cover mainly the strategic aspect of EXALT. The details about EXALT forces belong more to EXALT Missions article. [[User:Riw\|Riw]] ([[User talk:Riw\|talk]]) 22:03, 12 November 2021 (CET)
	:Yeah I hadn't gotten around to deciding where I wanted to put all the other info there exactly, I had been planning on taking what was in there and spreading it across [[Missions (Long War)\|Missions]], [[Alien Deployment (Long War)\|Alien Deployment]] or [[EXALT Units (Long War)\|EXALT Units]]. Speaking of which, the chart you added to [[Alien Research (Long War)\|Alien Research]] about how alien research affects alien stats doesn't really fit there, does it? It doesn't really detail how alien research affects aliens exactly, like what values of alien research add what stats. And of course if you start adding such info you're just duplicating what's already on [[Alien Life Forms (Long War)\|Alien Life Forms]]. I think just having a link to [[Alien Life Forms (Long War)\|Alien Life Forms]] like it had before is fine. [[User:DjinnFor\|DjinnFor]] ([[User talk:DjinnFor\|talk]]) 11:32, 13 November 2021 (CET)		:Yeah I hadn't gotten around to deciding where I wanted to put all the other info there exactly, I had been planning on taking what was in there and spreading it across [[Missions (Long War)\|Missions]], [[Alien Deployment (Long War)\|Alien Deployment]] or [[EXALT Units (Long War)\|EXALT Units]]. Speaking of which, the chart you added to [[Alien Research (Long War)\|Alien Research]] about how alien research affects alien stats doesn't really fit there, does it? It doesn't really detail how alien research affects aliens exactly, like what values of alien research add what stats. And of course if you start adding such info you're just duplicating what's already on [[Alien Life Forms (Long War)\|Alien Life Forms]]. I think just having a link to [[Alien Life Forms (Long War)\|Alien Life Forms]] like it had before is fine. [[User:DjinnFor\|DjinnFor]] ([[User talk:DjinnFor\|talk]]) 11:32, 13 November 2021 (CET)
			::Well, it's not duplication, since the table offers easy comparison of alien species, there is no such table in Alien Life Forms. Though I agree it might be better there, but then there is already a lot of stuff. Maybe we should create separate pages for every alien species, then in Life Forms would be just general overview including my comparison table. The table is not exactly detailed - it's not possible to put all the details in single table - but it does say what the alien stats are in the beginning, before 900 AR, after 900 AR, and after 1200 AR. For detailed info one can refer to Research tables in Alien Life Forms.[[User:Riw\|Riw]] ([[User talk:Riw\|talk]]) 12:54, 13 November 2021 (CET)

DjinnFor at 10:33, 13 November 2021

2021-11-13T10:33:07Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 10:33, 13 November 2021
Line 1:		Line 1:
	==EXALT Forces here?==		==EXALT Forces here?==
	DjinnFor, first of all, great job adding all these details. Though the tables in EXALT Forces are basically a duplicate of what is already in EXALT Missions article. It is not a good practice to have the same tables in two places. Consider removing them from here, as this article is meant to cover mainly the strategic aspect of EXALT. The details about EXALT forces belong more to EXALT Missions article. [[User:Riw\|Riw]] ([[User talk:Riw\|talk]]) 22:03, 12 November 2021 (CET)		DjinnFor, first of all, great job adding all these details. Though the tables in EXALT Forces are basically a duplicate of what is already in EXALT Missions article. It is not a good practice to have the same tables in two places. Consider removing them from here, as this article is meant to cover mainly the strategic aspect of EXALT. The details about EXALT forces belong more to EXALT Missions article. [[User:Riw\|Riw]] ([[User talk:Riw\|talk]]) 22:03, 12 November 2021 (CET)
			:Yeah I hadn't gotten around to deciding where I wanted to put all the other info there exactly, I had been planning on taking what was in there and spreading it across [[Missions (Long War)\|Missions]], [[Alien Deployment (Long War)\|Alien Deployment]] or [[EXALT Units (Long War)\|EXALT Units]]. Speaking of which, the chart you added to [[Alien Research (Long War)\|Alien Research]] about how alien research affects alien stats doesn't really fit there, does it? It doesn't really detail how alien research affects aliens exactly, like what values of alien research add what stats. And of course if you start adding such info you're just duplicating what's already on [[Alien Life Forms (Long War)\|Alien Life Forms]]. I think just having a link to [[Alien Life Forms (Long War)\|Alien Life Forms]] like it had before is fine. [[User:DjinnFor\|DjinnFor]] ([[User talk:DjinnFor\|talk]]) 11:32, 13 November 2021 (CET)

Riw: Created page with "==EXALT Forces here?== DjinnFor, first of all, great job adding all these details. Though the tables in EXALT Forces are basically a duplicate of what is already in EXALT Miss..."

2021-11-12T21:04:20Z

Created page with "==EXALT Forces here?== DjinnFor, first of all, great job adding all these details. Though the tables in EXALT Forces are basically a duplicate of what is already in EXALT Miss..."

New page

==EXALT Forces here?==
DjinnFor, first of all, great job adding all these details. Though the tables in EXALT Forces are basically a duplicate of what is already in EXALT Missions article. It is not a good practice to have the same tables in two places. Consider removing them from here, as this article is meant to cover mainly the strategic aspect of EXALT. The details about EXALT forces belong more to EXALT Missions article. [[User:Riw|Riw]] ([[User talk:Riw|talk]]) 22:03, 12 November 2021 (CET)